Very constructive; thanks! …


Comment posted Dragon’s Dogma Review by Joe Garcia.

Very constructive; thanks!

Recent comments by Joe Garcia

  • Max Payne 3’s arcade modes detailed
    I recently replayed both MP1&2 to get me ready for MP3, and while they’re still a lot of fun they’re definitely products of their time. What I played of MP3 at PAX East left me hopeful, as does the flood of positive reviews that came out for it today.
  • PS Uni Underground Radio 017: Basement Dweller
    New version is up. How sad is it that we’re the only commenters?
  • The Best Thing About PS Vita? PSN Games, Of Course
    Cool! Let me know what you think of them!
  • PS Uni Underground Radio 011: Congressman Chewbecca
    Yep, Mass Effect does indeed belong to EA.

    That’s not necessarily how a developer-publisher relationship works, though. Ideally, a publisher trusts a developer to make something that’s both fun and creative, while also being profitable for them. I’ve never heard of a publisher intervening about a specific plot point or gameplay mechanic, threatening to pull the plug if it isn’t changed. Usually when a game gets canned, it’s because it simply isn’t shaping up to be something worthwhile — remember NBA Elite?

  • PS Uni Underground Radio 011: Congressman Chewbecca
    I can’t agree with your second point. Almost everything ever made is created with the hopes of generating profit.

    Ultimately, my point is that, yeah, the ending to ME3 is a bit underwhelming in the scope of the entire series. Yet I still think that it’s highly thought-provoking, for better or worse.

    Frankly I’m just glad to see that a game’s story can be taken seriously enough to generate this kind of debate, whether I agree with the displeasure of others or not.

Readers Comments (7)

  1. Reneid Klein May 29, 2012 @ 05:10

    Good article. I agree with pretty much everything you said. However, I haven’t beaten the game yet. I know you had to rush it to get the review up and many of my friends are burning through it, but I’m taking my sweet time. At around 55 hours into the game and haven’t even fought a Griffin or Drake yet (ran into a Griffin 3x and I can’t get one to land and fight me, even if I shoot it. I saw a Drake in teh forest and ran from it like the biggest sissy in history.)

    Seeing that Drake walking in the forest out of nowhere gave me the same feeling that seeing that Tigrex for the first time on that Popo quest in Monster Hunter 2nd G. It was one of those “THAT’S NOT SUPPOSED TO BE HERE!!”. I just feel I am too weak to fight one now though I am itching to do it anyway. If I hadn’t been so far from home with so many supplies I would have likely tried it.

    In any case, I can’t say if the ending is good or bad yet because I barely got anywhere in the main story so far. Will probably be 150+ hours before I get the plat and that’s just fine with me.

    The fanboy in me wants to give it a perfect score but it’s not perfect. B+ is a fair score, though I personally would probably score it a bit higher at this point. Time will tell if the ending makes me drop my rating like ME3 did.

    Keep up the good work.

    • I’m currently playing through it again. I know what you mean about the Tigrex thing. A lot of this game reminded me of Monster Hunter (which is a good thing).

  2. Malcolm Spinedi May 29, 2012 @ 12:33

    Good article, nice detail. I think you gave it a really fair and honest review.

  3. bad game bad review

    • Very constructive; thanks!

      • Joe, you forget. His opinion is irrefutable fact. Possibly even law. Due to this, all other opinions are meaningless and even stupid.

        • Reneid Klein May 30, 2012 @ 00:21

          He meant “bad” as in like Michael Jackson “Bad”. As in “cool/awesome/radical”. So bad game bad review translates to “Awesome game and an amazing review”.

Comments are closed.